6 Great Ice Cream Places in and Around Muncie, IN

When you’re in the mood for something sweet, Muncie, IN is a great place to find delicious ice cream and other creamy concoctions. The classic vanilla and chocolate cones are sure to be on the menu, but there are dozens of other unique treats for you to discover while you’re on the road.

1. Insomnia Cookies

They’re famous for their cookies – ooey-gooey, warm, and delicious! Insomnia Cookies ships their baked goods nationwide, but in Muncie, you can visit their brick-and-mortar store for even more scrumptious sweets. With cookies such as cinnamon bun, double chocolate mint, and peanut butter cup, you are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth with a delicious cookiewich stuffed with a scoop of your favorite creamy flavor.

2. The Island Muncie

The Island is Indiana’s tropical oasis. Not only will you find refreshing sherbet and cooling cones, but the fruit smoothies are heavenly as well. Sipping on a mandarin orange passion fruit smoothie while resting in one of the many lounge chairs will have you feeling like you’re somewhere on a beach. What are you waiting for? Come unwind and treat yourself at The Island.

3. Mancino’s Sweet Shop

Mancino’s creatively uses their gourmet cookies in a variety of shakes and sundaes where customers can pick the cookie and gelato of their choice. Among many unique inventions, the Inside Out Peanut Butter Cup sandwich and Lemon Blueberry Blitz sandwich are two tasty treats that you’ll want to try!

4. The Barking Cow of Muncie

With a name like The Barking Cow, you know you’re in for a memorable visit. This creamery serves up over fifty flavors of scoopable goodness with house-made flavors such as Butter Beer, Dirty Banana, and Killer Keylime Pie. If you’re in the mood for something truly unique, you’ll find Cow Tippin’, Delaware County Pothole, Play Dough, Salty Jack, and Traffic Cone Blues in their freezer display.

5. Dairy Dream (Albany)

Dairy Dream is definitely a dream when it comes to creamy desserts. This shop is family-owned and operated since 1953. They see generations of visitors walk through every day, and because they have such a dedicated following, the Dairy Dream even has a Loyalty Club where you can collect points and earn rewards.

Need to cool down? Try the Hawaiian shaved ice. In the mood for something creamy? The large menu of sundaes, smoothies, floats, and Super Blitzes is sure to please. Or, stick with the classics and taste one of the hand-dipped cones. Amaretto cherry scooped into a waffle cone sounds simply decadent!

6. Sno Castle (Anderson)

If you’re craving something more lactose-friendly, the staff at Sno Castle have you covered with their refreshing menu of snow cones. Finding this little white castle is the easiest part; deciding on which flavor to try is sure to be a challenge! There are over sixty flavors of syrup with new flavors being introduced on a regular basis. To make your decision a bit easier, the sours come highly recommended!

There is no shortage of creamy desserts in the Muncie area. In fact, with so many options to choose from, you could be trying a different sundae, shake, or scoop every day of the week – we won’t judge! While you’re on the road, stop on by Kia of Muncie to check out all our new models. We’re committed to providing our customers with what they need, even if what you’re looking for is a soft-serve cone.

Image courtesy of Pexels

Tags: dessert, ice cream, ice cream shops, Muncie IN, sweets
Posted in Things to do in Muncie, IN | No Comments »